Profitability alone is no guarantee of resilience. For specialist IP firms, liquidity, client relationships, partner confidence and departure arrangements deserve attention while the business is performing well.

Recent reports that Weil Gotshal, one of the best-known names in international legal practice, is to wind down are striking given the scale and profitability associated with leading international law firms. Commentary on the story has focused on issues including partner departures, liquidity, financial commitments and the risk of a loss of confidence becoming self-reinforcing. A business can appear highly successful until confidence changes and departures begin to feed further departures.

It would be easy for FICPI members to see this as a Big Law story with little relevance to specialist IP practices. I think that would be a mistake. FICPI itself is constituted between intellectual property attorneys in private practice, and one of its aims is to collect and distribute information of professional interest for members. The underlying questions raised by the Weil story are worth considering in firms of every size.

Profit is not resilience

High profits per equity partner do not necessarily mean that a firm is financially strong. Poor cash conversion, generous distributions and significant fixed commitments can leave a profitable practice vulnerable to a sudden reduction in revenue.

The practical lesson is to manage liquidity separately from profitability. That means maintaining a rolling cash-flow forecast, paying close attention to work in progress and debt collection, and setting distributions with reference to future cash requirements rather than accounting profit alone.

“The practical lesson is to manage liquidity separately from profitability.”
 

Concentration is a structural risk

This is particularly relevant to IP firms. Many practices have important client relationships developed by individual partners over decades. Those relationships are valuable but can also create concentration risk.

If a leading partner leaves and clients follow, the earnings available to the remaining partners fall. That may affect confidence in the firm's future and encourage further departures. A manageable problem can become self-reinforcing.

Management boards should therefore stress-test the departure of an important partner, or an entire team, together with the clients likely to follow them.

The better long-term protection is not simply contractual restrictions. It is to make key client relationships genuinely institutional: several meaningful contacts within the firm, deliberate introduction of the next generation and succession arrangements agreed before they become necessary.

Partner confidence matters

Financial resilience depends partly on confidence.

Partners need credible financial information, a strategy they understand and clarity about leadership succession. Uncertainty over any of those can magnify an otherwise manageable setback.

A cluster of senior departures should therefore be treated as a governance and financial-risk event, not simply a recruitment problem.

Look at departure provisions through a financial lens

Partnership agreements understandably focus on notice periods, garden leave, restrictive covenants and team moves. But there is another potential problem: what happens when a firm loses the earnings generated by departing partners while simultaneously having to repay their capital?

Either might be manageable alone. Together, particularly if several partners leave within a short period, they can put significant pressure on cash.

Notice provisions, restrictions and capital repayment should therefore be considered as parts of the same contingency framework. Subject to local law and specialist advice, firms might consider whether their agreements can provide flexibility over capital repayment during genuine financial stress, based on objective criteria agreed in advance.
 

“Arrangements devised during a crisis will be much harder to agree.”


Avoid rewarding the first to leave

A dangerous dynamic develops if partners believe that those who leave first will be better protected than those who stay. Actions that are individually rational can collectively destabilise a viable firm.

Management should understand beforehand how capital, existing liabilities, transition costs and the interests of partners who remain to run the business would be dealt with in a serious departure scenario.

Nor should firms assume that punitive exit provisions provide an easy solution. Their enforceability varies by jurisdiction and they may have unintended commercial consequences.

Four questions for management

I would encourage FICPI members involved in managing their firms to put four questions to their boards:

  1. Cash: What happens to our liquidity if a significant partner, team or client leaves?
  2. Clients: Which important relationships depend too heavily on one individual?
  3. Confidence: Do partners understand our strategy and succession arrangements?
  4. Contracts: Do our partnership agreement and financial contingency plan actually work together under stress?
     

Contractual protections can buy time, but they cannot substitute for a resilient business. The strongest protection is a firm whose client relationships extend beyond individuals and whose partners have good reasons to remain together.

The best time to test that resilience is while the firm is performing well.

 

FICPI's view

FICPI uniquely combines education and advocacy on topics around practice management, patents and trade marks, with a focus on developing the professional excellence of its individual members. FICPI Forums, Congress, committees and meetings are opportunities to gather insights from the international IP attorney community on any issue, whether it be practice-related or topics of patent and trade mark law.

Next steps

 


Sources
• Reuters, “Weil Collapse Shows the Fragility Behind Big Law's Billions”, 29 October 2026
• Oxford Law Blogs, “Why Law Firms Collapse”, 3 June 2019
• Bloomberg Law, “Partners Who Stay Through Firm Collapse Need Defined Protections”, 31 October 2026
• PKF Francis Clark, “Key Financial Stability Measures in Law Firms”, 29 April 2026
• CM Murray LLP, “The Little Book of Partner Exits and Team Moves”, 2016